Home » Latest » Premier League Panel Split Over Jayden Bogle Challenge on Mathys Tel After Tottenham Complaint

Premier League Panel Split Over Jayden Bogle Challenge on Mathys Tel After Tottenham Complaint

Tottenham Hotspur have lodged a formal complaint with refereeing body Pro Ref following the decision not to send off Leeds United defender Jayden Bogle for his challenge on Mathys Tel.

The incident occurred during Tottenham’s 1-0 defeat at Elland Road on Saturday, November 7. Bogle caught Tel high around the ankle and Achilles area during the first half, but referee John Brooks did not show a card and VAR did not recommend an on-field review.

The Standard reported on November 9 that Tottenham had filed an official complaint with Pro Ref after the match. The club is understood to want an explanation of why the challenge was not punished with a red card.

Tottenham seek explanation over Bogle challenge

The challenge was reviewed by VAR for around four minutes, but the original decision was upheld. Bogle escaped without a booking, while Tel was unable to continue and was replaced before half-time.

The Independent had reported immediately after the game that Spurs intended to write to Pro Ref to seek clarification over the decision. The later report from The Standard stated that the complaint had been formally filed.

The incident has attracted further scrutiny from former officials. Speaking on Sky Sports’ Ref Watch, former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher said: “I think it is a red card,” arguing that the contact around the Achilles area was a key factor in his assessment. His comments were reported by The Standard.

Premier League panel split over Bogle’s challenge on Tel

The Premier League has now published the independent Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel’s assessment of the incident. In its Match Round 10 findings, released on Wednesday, November 18, the panel voted 3-2 that referee John Brooks was correct not to show Bogle a red card. The same 3-2 split supported VAR’s decision not to recommend an on-field review.

The panel agreed that the challenge was a clear foul and described the contact as “very clearly reckless”. However, the majority felt Bogle was attempting to challenge with his right leg and that his left foot came down on the back of Tel’s ankle without the speed, force or intensity required for serious foul play. Two panellists disagreed and believed the challenge was sufficiently dangerous to warrant a red card. The full KMI decision document records the split vote and the panel’s reasoning.

The finding means the independent panel backed the original no-red-card decision, but it was not unanimous. It does not change the result of Tottenham’s 1-0 defeat at Leeds or provide any further medical information about Tel’s injury.

De Zerbi refused to blame officials for Leeds defeat

Despite his frustration during the match, Roberto De Zerbi was careful when asked about the incident in his post-match press conference. He said he had not seen the challenge clearly enough to give a definitive verdict and insisted that he had confidence in the referee and VAR.

“I can’t say something more because I didn’t see clearly the situation,” De Zerbi said in the club’s official transcript of his post-match press conference. He later added that Tottenham needed to focus on their own performance and the areas where they could improve.

The head coach’s comments came after a defeat in which Spurs struggled to maintain their first-half level. Noah Okafor scored Leeds’ only goal in the 79th minute, ending Tottenham’s three-match winning run. The full match account is available in Spurs Only’s Leeds 1-0 Tottenham report.

Tel injury remains a separate concern for Spurs

The complaint is separate from the medical situation surrounding Tel. De Zerbi described the forward’s injury as a “bad injury” after the game, and Tel subsequently withdrew from the France Under-21 squad for the November international window.

Tottenham have not confirmed a return date for the forward. Supporters can read our initial report on De Zerbi’s Mathys Tel injury update and the latest update on his withdrawal from France Under-21 duty for the developments on his fitness.

The KMI Panel published its assessment on Wednesday, November 18. The panel’s review is separate from Tottenham’s complaint: the published verdict records the independent panel’s view of the refereeing decisions, while the club’s request for an explanation should not be presented as having changed that outcome. Tel’s recovery remains a separate concern, with no confirmed return date published by Tottenham at the time of writing.

Scroll To Top